PDA

View Full Version : Des Baker Competition Entry


zebedak
27-06-2006, 23:54
Hey - this is the entry me and two of my friends sent into the Des Baker Competition in South Africa (one of the leading student arch competions here - and only two entires were allowed from each institute). We didnt win it - but thought i'd try get some crits from u guys here

low res video clip (http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4899775135386917077)
high res video clip (http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=6108791835467195825 )

The Brief

The over all theme this year was “The Legacy of Tectonics in Architecture”

Architecture as a catalyst for the needs and aspirations of a South African community through the use of available resources.

Basically the brief was to identify a need within any South African community and provide a suitable solution to this need, while exploring ‘poetry of assembly’. It could also address issues such as safety, social, health care or commercial needs or could relate to sport, religion or art.

The Concept:

The idea for our project came when walking through the streets of central Johannesburg and noticing the over abundance of litter and overflowing garbage bins. From here we took a look into the current recycling program running within Jo’burg, and finding out that it was insufficient at the present moment. So we decided to do a garbage bin for recycling, but not just simply a garbage bin (spent more time on this than on any building we had designed so far :) ).

So for now, the main focus of our was on central Johannesburg, but we also took a look at other key areas around Johannesburg, namely Alexandra and Melrose, but these only as a side project.

The Design:

So the idea for our bins went along these lines:
1. To make the bins create a “path” through the city, not a path as such, but rather they link to one another and lead one to the many garden centers throughout the city
2. They can also reconfigure so that they don’t get monotonous, and also so that they can fit into different sized spaces, e.g. long and narrow for street edge, or spread out for parks, etc.
3. Also, the cage above the bins is for street artist to display art created from recycled materials, etc. They also act as lighting by means of a ‘tray’ of L.E.D’s placed at the bottom of the cage.
4. The bins are also color coded as to which item (glass, plastic, paper and tin) goes in which bin.
5. The garden centers are larger, park like areas within the city, where people who wish to recycle larger amounts can take their recyclable garbage and dump it into the provided bins. They get cash for every kilogram of material recycled – as it works in current garden centers. The reason for more garden centres within the city is because the current ones are often too far and scattered for everyone to access – this was an issue brought up by Piki-tup (a recyling company) when we spoke to them.

If there is any more u want to know just let me know. Thanks :)

(please note: i suck with words :D )


Page 1

18767

zebedak
27-06-2006, 23:57
Page 2

18768

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:01
Page 3

18771

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:02
Page 4

18772

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:05
Page 5

18773

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:07
Page 6

18774

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:08
Page 7

18775

zebedak
28-06-2006, 00:10
page 8

18776

Cool - thats all the pages - might post up some views from close up later. :)

feigetl
28-06-2006, 01:21
Post up the clip, I think that was one of the best parts of your presentation. And by the way if I get my rep-ping act together and organise the fundraiser studio party/gallery event, you guys must (ie. will be forced by me ;)) to display it.

feigetl
28-06-2006, 01:26
Post up the clip

sorry perhaps a trip to the optometrist is in order

zebedak
28-06-2006, 01:29
Post up the clip, I think that was one of the best parts of your presentation. And by the way if I get my rep-ping act together and organise the fundraiser studio party/gallery event, you guys must (ie. will be forced by me ;)) to display it.

just the clip :) im ok with that - the rest will give us nightmares :) spent soo damn long on it - and the clip is there - right at the top

zebedak
28-06-2006, 23:02
bin from front

18823

zebedak
28-06-2006, 23:03
one of the many configurations of the bins

18824

zebedak
28-06-2006, 23:05
the bin in context (abstract)

18825

zebedak
28-06-2006, 23:06
a night render

18826

zebedak
29-06-2006, 23:14
ok - so seeing as all the other pages are soo small - iv hosted a large pic on another site if you would like to be able to see what is actually happening. Also put a zip file if you would rather view it that way :)

all the pages (large) (http://img442.imageshack.us/img442/2311/allpages0gr.jpg)

18867

coral
29-06-2006, 23:42
Overall it seems like a simple clean design, except for the cage-like bars, what are those being used for? They don't seem to fit into the language you already have going.
I like the idea of using very utilitarian and necessary items in a downtown as an identity marker, which are usually very additive like signage or clocktowers.

zebedak
29-06-2006, 23:52
Overall it seems like a simple clean design, except for the cage-like bars, what are those being used for? They don't seem to fit into the language you already have going.
I like the idea of using very utilitarian and necessary items in a downtown as an identity marker, which are usually very additive like signage or clocktowers.

Thanks - and cage like bars - the ones at the bottm - those are so that the bins can be configured into different positions - the idea that all the connections are identical therfore allowing for a larger variety of configurations. Hope that answers that :)

imasayer
30-06-2006, 00:14
Thanks - and cage like bars - the ones at the bottm - those are so that the bins can be configured into different positions - the idea that all the connections are identical therfore allowing for a larger variety of configurations. Hope that answers that :)

Why different configurations? How does that benefit you? To me it just seems additive, and unnecessary.

feigetl
30-06-2006, 00:17
Why different configurations? How does that benefit you? To me it just seems additive, and unnecessary.

I think the reason was so that they can fit into different spaces, some tightly cramped and others spacious.?

zebedak
30-06-2006, 00:21
I think the reason was so that they can fit into different spaces, some tightly cramped and others spacious.?

spot on - the idea is that the bin can go anywhere - in a park for instance you wouldnt need it to be long and narrow - its so that it doesnt become repetitive and boring - the idea bein that you would want to go and throw ur rubbish in the bin because it looks good too

imasayer
30-06-2006, 00:21
I can't imagine what that space would be in an urban setting. If it was a tight space, why would you want it there in the first place. I really wish I could read the boards. (Sorry, I see you have a link that I missed, I will look at the larger boards)

imasayer
30-06-2006, 00:36
After reading the boards:

I like the iconic nature of the design. I think that would help people take notice of the bins and use them more, something that may actually help the litter problem.

2 comments:

1. When I first saw this project I was under the impression that things moved. I kind of like this idea. If you are going to have such an elaborate connection system, why not make it more of an interactive sculpture. I don't think that being able to arrange them in different ways really offers you much. They could be simplified and still do the same job without being boring as you say.

2. You have not addressed the issue (as far as I can tell) of how the recyclables can be collected and taken away easily by truck. Tell me if I have missed something here.

zebedak
30-06-2006, 00:51
You have not addressed the issue (as far as I can tell) of how the recyclables can be collected and taken away easily by truck. Tell me if I have missed something here.

hmm - good point - it didnt really come across in the images - but the idea was sort of portrayed on the first page in the comic - or rather an attempt of covering it - also on page 4 (bag removal - bottom left) - each bag is color coded according to the type of litter to go into it (page 1) and then the bags are collect by means of the current refuse collection (but increased in number) - the bags are then sorted by color when they arrive at the processing plant (page1) and recycled (the litter) - there is a plan of implementation which i will try find (not sure who kept it) and post.

thanks for the crits so far :)

zebedak
30-06-2006, 01:11
Plan of Implementaion (unrevised version)

sorry - i dont have the updated one - but pretty similar

?eter
30-06-2006, 08:35
2. You have not addressed the issue (as far as I can tell) of how the recyclables can be collected and taken away easily by truck. Tell me if I have missed something here.
There is a fair amount of informal recycling that happens in Joburg at the moment. I imagine that in reality all of the 'paper' dustbins would be cleared out by paper recyclers collecting paper. Maybe a series of recyclers collect this waste (a formalisation of the existing situation) rather than collection by pikitup (http://www.pikitup.co.za/) (joburg's refuse service) and distribution from a central point?

?eter
30-06-2006, 08:44
As for the variety of different configurations, I like the idea, but I suppose it might not be 100% necessary. But the idea of variety is pretty cool- it's not imossible that you could get architecture geeks travelling around photographing them.

goldthang
30-06-2006, 08:46
B"H

I like the Idea of cleaning up Joburg... it really needs it.. Adding design into the development is always a good thing...

In Israel they have a huge plastic recycling program that seemed highly successful. It lacks design but gets the job done.

zebedak
30-06-2006, 12:28
There is a fair amount of informal recycling that happens in Joburg at the moment. I imagine that in reality all of the 'paper' dustbins would be cleared out by paper recyclers collecting paper. Maybe a series of recyclers collect this waste (a formalisation of the existing situation) rather than collection by pikitup (http://www.pikitup.co.za/) (joburg's refuse service) and distribution from a central point?

Actually pickitup does do this currently - went and had a chat with them. For instance - at the garden centres currently in existance - they are run by pickitup, and all the diffferent wastes types are collected by them, then people such and mondi (paper) and collect-a-can, etc. go to them and collect the appropriate material. :D

Pedro Barradas
20-02-2007, 23:58
:bump: what happened to this competition?

shmoolikipod
21-02-2007, 14:55
For Pedro:


Hey - this is the entry me and two of my friends sent into the Des Baker Competition in South Africa . We didnt win it - but thought


:cheers:

zebedak
21-02-2007, 15:00
:bump: what happened to this competition?

theres another one this year (every year actually) and this time its feige and her class that get to have a go - im interested to see what comes out :wondering

mperna
21-02-2007, 15:07
:craqueur: Outstanding graphics- I really like your presentation...

Have they announced the winner?

feigetl
21-02-2007, 16:26
theres another one this year (every year actually) and this time its feige and her class that get to have a go - im interested to see what comes out :wondering

The topic this year is "The In Between" I have some ideas formulating and we have 5 weeks to do it, so shall post my work then.

zebedak
21-02-2007, 17:33
u had better formulate fast - nothing worse than having to do crunch time on sucha big proj - believe me , i was bad - and that seems awfuly soon - last time we had until like may or something - or is that just the preliminary presentation?

feigetl
21-02-2007, 19:23
The whole thing I think-congress is april 1-6, so we def dont have till May.